The $15 Billion Bitcoin Seizure: Inside the Lubian Mining Pool, Weak Randomness, and the 5-Year-Old Milk Sad Mystery

2025-10-21 07:24:40
Bitcoin
Article Rating : 4.6
half-star
0 ratings
The U.S. government recently seized 127,271 Bitcoins (approximately $15 billion), with the case tracing back to a key vulnerability caused by a weak random algorithm used by the Lubian Mining Pool in 2020. Researchers found that this batch of "Milk Sad Wallets" had been quietly drained by the end of 2020, becoming one of the largest invisible security incidents in crypto history.
The $15 Billion Bitcoin Seizure: Inside the Lubian Mining Pool, Weak Randomness, and the 5-Year-Old Milk Sad Mystery

The largest Bitcoin seizure case in American history

In October 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York disclosed that the U.S. government had seized 127,271 Bitcoins, valued at approximately $15 billion at market price. These Bitcoins were identified as significant assets in the money laundering network of the Cambodian Prince Group. The U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) has now taken over these Bitcoins and completed the transfer of 9,757 BTC to the official custody address on October 15.

Community analysis suggests that this batch of Bitcoin is closely related to the Lubian Mining Pool that mysteriously disappeared in 2020 - that security disaster known as the ‘Milk Sad incident’ may have been a precursor to this seizure.

From Lubian to Prince Group: The Flow of Funds Comes to Light

Lubian Mining Pool suddenly rose in 2020, with no background and no official website, yet quickly occupied about 6% of global hash power. It was later discovered that its private key generation mechanism had serious randomness vulnerabilities. Server controlled by Chen Zhi, an executive of the Prince Group, and his family allegedly stored some wallet mnemonics or private key files. The indictment from the U.S. Department of Justice pointed out that Lubian Mining Pool was used to “launder newly mined cryptocurrency assets.”

Mersenne Twister: A time bomb buried in the wallet generator

The random number algorithm Mersenne Twister MT19937-32 used by Lubian is not a cryptographically secure random source. Its output has periodic patterns that can be exploited by hackers through brute force enumeration to deduce private keys. The Milk Sad research team pointed out that at least 53,500 BTC were stored in such “weak private key wallets” between 2019 and 2020, including whale-level addresses and miner reward wallets.

The outbreak and concealment of weak random number attacks

On December 28, 2020, a large number of Lubian-related addresses were emptied within a few hours, with approximately 136,951 BTC (about 3.7 billion USD) transferred out. The transaction fees were consistent, and the operations were precise, demonstrating a high level of technical proficiency. However, the incident was not initially viewed as a hacking attack; some in the community even considered it a mining pool reorganization. It wasn’t until a few years later that the Milk Sad team reverse-engineered the random number vulnerability, revealing this chain disaster.

From Trust Wallet to bx seed: Reproducing the chain vulnerability

This randomness vulnerability is not an isolated case. Between 2022 and 2023, Trust Wallet and Libbitcoin Explorer 3.x were both found to use the same MT19937 algorithm, resulting in the theft of hundreds of BTC. In August 2023, after the Milk Sad team publicly disclosed the bx seed vulnerability, it was found that its historical victim timeframe overlapped with that of the Lubian wallet, and the timing of large on-chain fund transfers also matched perfectly with the events at the end of 2020.

The truth five years later: randomness is the final line of defense.

The latest case disclosed by the U.S. Department of Justice has finally brought this dormant whale, which has been asleep for 5 years, back to the surface. These Bitcoins are considered to come from wallets with “randomness failure,” ultimately falling into the control of money laundering groups. As researchers say: “Not your keys, not your coins—but the premise is that this key really needs to be random.”

* The information is not intended to be and does not constitute financial advice or any other recommendation of any sort offered or endorsed by Gate.
Related Articles
XZXX: A Comprehensive Guide to the BRC-20 Meme Token in 2025

XZXX: A Comprehensive Guide to the BRC-20 Meme Token in 2025

XZXX emerges as the leading BRC-20 meme token of 2025, leveraging Bitcoin Ordinals for unique functionalities that integrate meme culture with tech innovation. The article explores the token's explosive growth, driven by a thriving community and strategic market support from exchanges like Gate, while offering beginners a guided approach to purchasing and securing XZXX. Readers will gain insights into the token's success factors, technical advancements, and investment strategies within the expanding XZXX ecosystem, highlighting its potential to reshape the BRC-20 landscape and digital asset investment.
2025-08-21 07:56:36
Bitcoin Fear and Greed Index: Market Sentiment Analysis for 2025

Bitcoin Fear and Greed Index: Market Sentiment Analysis for 2025

As the Bitcoin Fear and Greed Index plummets below 10 in April 2025, cryptocurrency market sentiment reaches unprecedented lows. This extreme fear, coupled with Bitcoin's 80,000−85,000 price range, highlights the complex interplay between crypto investor psychology and market dynamics. Our Web3 market analysis explores the implications for Bitcoin price predictions and blockchain investment strategies in this volatile landscape.
2025-08-14 05:20:00
5 ways to get Bitcoin for free in 2025: Newbie Guide

5 ways to get Bitcoin for free in 2025: Newbie Guide

In 2025, getting Bitcoin for free has become a hot topic. From microtasks to gamified mining, to Bitcoin reward credit cards, there are numerous ways to obtain free Bitcoin. This article will reveal how to easily earn Bitcoin in 2025, explore the best Bitcoin faucets, and share Bitcoin mining techniques that require no investment. Whether you are a newbie or an experienced user, you can find a suitable way to get rich with cryptocurrency here.
2025-08-14 05:17:05
Top Crypto ETFs to Watch in 2025: Navigating the Digital Asset Boom

Top Crypto ETFs to Watch in 2025: Navigating the Digital Asset Boom

Cryptocurrency Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) have become a cornerstone for investors seeking exposure to digital assets without the complexities of direct ownership. Following the landmark approval of spot Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs in 2024, the crypto ETF market has exploded, with $65 billion in inflows and Bitcoin surpassing $100,000. As 2025 unfolds, new ETFs, regulatory developments, and institutional adoption are set to drive further growth. This article highlights the top crypto ETFs to watch in 2025, based on assets under management (AUM), performance, and innovation, while offering insights into their strategies and risks.
2025-08-14 05:10:01
Bitcoin Market Cap in 2025: Analysis and Trends for Investors

Bitcoin Market Cap in 2025: Analysis and Trends for Investors

The Bitcoin market cap has reached a staggering **2.05 trillion** in 2025, with the Bitcoin price soaring to **$103,146**. This unprecedented growth reflects the cryptocurrency market capitalization's evolution and underscores the impact of blockchain technology on Bitcoin. Our Bitcoin investment analysis reveals key market trends shaping the digital currency landscape through 2025 and beyond.
2025-08-14 04:51:40
2025 Bitcoin Price Prediction: Trump's Tariffs' Impact on BTC

2025 Bitcoin Price Prediction: Trump's Tariffs' Impact on BTC

This article discusses the impact of Trump's 2025 tariffs on Bitcoin, analyzes price fluctuations, institutional investors' reactions, and Bitcoin's safe haven status. The article explores how the depreciation of the US dollar is advantageous to Bitcoin, while also questioning its correlation with gold. This article provides insights for investors in market fluctuations, considering geopolitical factors and macroeconomic trends, and offers updated forecasts for the price of Bitcoin in 2025.
2025-08-14 05:18:32
Recommended for You
Gate Ventures Insights: DeFi 2.0—Curator Strategy Layers Rise as RWA Emerges as a New Foundational Asset

Gate Ventures Insights: DeFi 2.0—Curator Strategy Layers Rise as RWA Emerges as a New Foundational Asset

Gain access to proprietary analysis, investment theses, and deep dives into the projects shaping the future of digital assets, featuring the latest frontier technology analysis and ecosystem developments.
2026-03-18 11:44:58
Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 16, 2026)

Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 16, 2026)

Stay ahead of the market with our Weekly Crypto Report, covering macro trends, a full crypto markets overview, and the key crypto highlights.
2026-03-16 13:34:19
Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 9, 2026)

Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 9, 2026)

Stay ahead of the market with our Weekly Crypto Report, covering macro trends, a full crypto markets overview, and the key crypto highlights.
2026-03-09 16:14:07
Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 2, 2026)

Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (March 2, 2026)

Stay ahead of the market with our Weekly Crypto Report, covering macro trends, a full crypto markets overview, and the key crypto highlights.
2026-03-02 23:20:41
Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (February 23, 2026)

Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (February 23, 2026)

Stay ahead of the market with our Weekly Crypto Report, covering macro trends, a full crypto markets overview, and the key crypto highlights.
2026-02-24 06:42:31
Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (February 9, 2026)

Gate Ventures Weekly Crypto Recap (February 9, 2026)

Stay ahead of the market with our Weekly Crypto Report, covering macro trends, a full crypto markets overview, and the key crypto highlights.
2026-02-09 20:15:46