Bank for International Settlements Warns: Stablecoins Are More Like Securities, Redemption Flaws Could Trigger a Bank Run

DEFI-5,74%

Stablecoins and Securities

BIS (Bank for International Settlements) Director General Pablo Hernández de Cos warned on Monday at a conference in Japan hosted by the Bank of Japan that the global stablecoin market has surpassed $315.9 billion, but its operating mechanism is closer to investment products such as ETFs rather than genuine money. BIS said that once large-scale redemptions occur, it will trigger a chain-run effect similar to the one seen in 2023 at Silicon Valley Bank.

Highly concentrated market: USDT and USDC control 85% of the share

The stablecoin market structure is highly concentrated, with Tether (USDT) and Circle (USDC) together accounting for about 85% of circulating market share. USDT has a market value of about $186.0 billion, while USDC is about $78.8 billion. Pablo Hernández de Cos believes that this level of concentration reflects systemic importance and also highlights structural flaws in the way existing stablecoin arrangements function as payment instruments. While stablecoins offer advantages such as fast cross-border transfers and the ability to integrate with smart contracts, without an effective international regulatory framework, they will have a major impact on financial stability and monetary policy.

Redemption flaws and financial contagion risk: a run mechanism like SVB

The “redemption frictions” of stablecoins are the core risk point that BIS is most concerned about. In the primary market, issuers often set redemption fees or impose limiting conditions, and secondary-market prices frequently deviate from the $1 peg. As a result, during periods of stress, stablecoins cannot remain as stable as traditional fiat currencies. Once the market sees large-scale withdrawals, issuers are forced to sell reserve assets in an already pressured market. This not only transmits funding pressure into the banking system, but may also depress the prices of related assets, triggering chain effects on banks holding similar assets. To mitigate such risks, some policymakers are considering limiting interest paid on stablecoin holdings, or allowing regulated issuers to access central bank lending facilities or mechanisms similar to deposit insurance.

Fragmented regulation and loopholes for illegal financing

Regulatory progress worldwide is uneven. FSB Chair and Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey said that the international rulemaking process has stalled. The U.S. “CLARITY Act” is currently under consideration in the Senate. While the issue of stablecoin yields has partially reached compromise, there are still disagreements over DeFi regulation and professional ethics standards. BIS specifically noted that stablecoin usage relies on non-custodial wallets and public blockchains, with a large share of activity lying outside traditional AML and CTF monitoring. Unless specialized safeguards are implemented in on-off ramps, it is easy for stablecoins to become tools for the flow of illicit funds.

European countries step up countermeasures against dollar stablecoins, fueling a battle over the fiat map

Against a backdrop of tightening regulation, European countries are actively adjusting their strategies. French Finance Minister Roland Lescure urged Europe’s banking sector to expand the issuance of euro-denominated stablecoins, and Denis Beau, Deputy Governor of the Banque de France, suggested revising MiCA rules to restrict the use of non-euro stablecoins in everyday payments. UBS launched a Swiss franc stablecoin pilot in early April 2026. Demand is also continuing to grow—according to a BVNK survey, among 15 countries, 54% of respondents held stablecoins in the past year, and 56% plan to increase their holdings. For some freelancers and e-commerce sellers, stablecoin payments have accounted for 35% of their annual revenue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does BIS say stablecoins are more like securities than money?

BIS pointed out that stablecoin issuers set redemption fees and impose limiting conditions in the primary market, and that secondary-market prices frequently deviate from the $1 peg. These features align more with the behavior of ETFs or investment products than with the unconditional convertibility that genuine money should have. Therefore, BIS believes they are more akin to securities in terms of regulatory classification.

Why can stablecoin redemption mechanisms create systemic risks similar to bank runs?

Stablecoin issuers typically hold short-term government bonds and bank deposits as reserves. Once large-scale redemption demand arises, issuers are forced to sell reserves in markets that are already under pressure. This not only pushes down the prices of related assets, but may also have ripple effects on banks holding similar assets—similar to the runs triggered in 2023 at Silicon Valley Bank, when bond asset losses forced it to sell.

What are the latest developments in global stablecoin regulation right now?

Regulatory progress is uneven: the U.S. “CLARITY Act” is still pending in the Senate, and there are disagreements over DeFi provisions; Europe’s MiCA framework faces pressure for revisions to limit non-euro stablecoins; the Bank of England’s governor said that international rulemaking has fallen into a stalemate; Swiss UBS has launched a fiat stablecoin pilot; China continues its ban on offshore yuan stablecoins, but Circle CEO predicts China may launch related products within 3 to 5 years.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to Disclaimer.

Related Articles

Bank of Japan Likely to Hold Rates at April 28 Meeting, But Maintains Hawkish Stance

Summary: BoJ is likely to hold at 0.75% on April 28 while signaling future rate hikes if conditions permit; June action remains possible, with some officials leaning toward a near-term move amid inflation risks from geopolitical shocks and a higher forecast. Abstract: The Bank of Japan is expected to keep its policy rate at 0.75% at the April 28 meeting, signaling eventual hikes as conditions permit; discussion centers on timing and a potential June move, in light of geopolitical tensions and an updated inflation outlook.

GateNews3h ago

Bank of Korea Governor Outlines CBDC, Deposit Token Expansion and Won Internationalization Strategy

South Korea's central bank Governor Shin Hyun-song aims to promote CBDCs and deposit tokens through Project Hangang Phase 2, emphasizing digital payment innovation and financial stability while signaling a softening stance on stablecoins.

GateNews8h ago

Kevin Warsh 成首位「Tech Bro」Fed 主席提名人:AI 樂觀派、持 SpaceX 與 Polymarket 股份

Kevin Warsh, nominated by Trump, becomes the first “Tech Bro” Fed chair, closely connected with Silicon Valley giants, and argues that AI can reduce inflation and supports an accommodative monetary policy. His Silicon Valley background could influence the Fed’s interest-rate decisions; expectations for the crypto market are positive, but the risk of conflicts of interest also needs to be considered. His appointment process and future policy direction will affect the U.S. Dollar Index and valuations of Taiwan stocks.

ChainNewsAbmedia20h ago

BIS calls for globally coordinated stablecoin regulation: warns that Tether and Circle account for 85% of those showing “security-like characteristics”

The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) once again emphasized the importance of global stablecoin regulatory coordination, pointing out three major risks that stablecoins face at this stage, including regulatory challenges related to cross-border flows and issues with market concentration. BIS proposed a unified ledger framework and argued that central banks need to lead the development of digital currencies, which would pose challenges to existing stablecoin issuers such as Tether and Circle. Overall, in the future, stablecoins may face a more stringent regulatory framework.

ChainNewsAbmedia04-20 09:45

ETH drops 0.56% in 15 minutes: Institutions’ ETF in-and-out flows and tightened on-chain liquidity dominate the market

From 17:45 to 18:00 (UTC) on 2026-04-19, the ETH price recorded a return of -0.56% within 15 minutes, closing in the 2294.03 - 2311.0 USDT range, with an amplitude of 0.73%. Heightened market volatility triggered increased short-term trading activity and boosted attention, while overall liquidity performance tightened. The main driving force behind this unusual move is institutions’ short-term in-and-out flows of ETF funds and a lull in on-chain stablecoin activity. In early April, after the ETH spot ETF recorded a net inflow of $120.24 million over a short period, it quickly reversed to a net outflow of $64.61 million, indicating that institutional capital became more short-term and there was no signal of sustained accumulation. Meanwhile, on-chain USDT and USDC activity fell in tandem to an annual low; ETH’s short-term buying power was clearly insufficient, putting pressure on liquidity. In addition, high-win-rate whales have been frequently shorting ETH and BTC since April 14, with related position sizes exceeding $25 million, further intensifying downward pressure in the short term. On the macro front, the Federal Reserve maintains high interest rates, the U.S. dollar remains strong, risk appetite has shifted to cautious, and some funds have flowed into traditional assets such as U.S. stocks. On-chain data shows that exchange reserves for ETH have fallen to the lowest level in nearly a decade, suggesting that long-term holders are actively shifting away from self-custody, further reducing market liquidity supply and amplifying price anomalies. Network conditions are stable; gas fees are operating at low levels, and on-chain transactions have not shown extreme spikes. The risk of near-term fluctuations remains high. ETF fund flows, large on-chain transfers, stablecoin activity, and changes in whale positions will be key indicators to watch. If institutions step up selling or stablecoin outflows expand further, ETH price volatility may intensify. Please continue to monitor macro developments and on-chain liquidity changes, stay alert to the risk of sharp short-term volatility, and get more real-time updates.

GateNews04-19 18:02

UBS Expects Fed to Cut Rates 50 Basis Points by Year-End; 10-Year Treasury Yield Forecast at 3.75%

UBS analysts predict the Federal Reserve will cut interest rates by 50 basis points by 2026, despite rising energy prices. Fed Chairman Powell suggests limited tightening is needed, focusing on core inflation evidence before cuts. The forecast for Treasury yields indicates potential downward movement.

GateNews04-18 19:11
Comment
0/400
No comments